| Date of PNE Debut | Forenames | Surname | Total PNE Goals |
| 23/08/1986 | SAMUEL (SAM) | ALLARDYCE | 4 |
| 09/12/1985 | VERNON | ALLATT | 4 |
| 04/05/1935 | Andrew (Andy) | Beattie | 4 |
| 21/02/1934 | Frank E | Beresford | 4 |
| 25/03/2014 | ALAN | BROWNE | 4 |
| 10/11/1934 | Albert | Butterworth | 4 |
| 10/01/1891 | William Cecil | Campbell | 4 |
| 25/08/2003 | CLAUDE | DAVIS | 4 |
| 13/09/1890 | Jack | Drummond | 4 |
| 05/09/1898 | Joseph (Joe) | Elliott | 4 |
| 29/11/1913 | John | Ford | 4 |
| 18/03/1967 | JAMES (JIM) | FORREST | 4 |
| 17/08/1985 | WAYNE PAUL | FOSTER | 4 |
| 13/03/1948 | WILLIAM KING (WILLIE) | HANNAH | 4 |
| 20/01/1968 | GRAHAM NORMAN | HAWKINS | 4 |
| 07/08/2010 | PAUL EDWARD | HAYES | 4 |
| 28/04/2012 | WILLIAM (WILL) | HAYHURST | 4 |
| 12/01/1935 | John Arthur | Hetherington | 4 |
| 07/05/1988 | ADRIAN FRANCIS | HUGHES | 4 |
| 03/02/1968 | KENNETH (KEN) | KNIGHTON | 4 |
| 25/12/1922 | Alexander (Sandy) | Laird | 4 |
| 20/09/1958 | JOHN GILBERT (GIL) | LAMBERT | 4 |
| 18/09/1999 | ALEXANDER (ALEX) | MATHIE | 4 |
| 05/09/1903 | James C (Jimmy) | McLean | 4 |
| 19/10/2002 | TYRONE | MEARS | 4 |
| 17/08/1993 | GAVIN MARK | NEBBELING | 4 |
| 01/12/1956 | FRANCIS (FRANK) | O'FARRELL | 4 |
| 17/03/1934 | John (Jack) | Pears | 4 |
| 02/02/2010 | JAMIE | PROCTOR | 4 |
| 05/11/1949 | FREDERICK THOMAS (FRED) | RAMSCAR | 4 |
| 15/08/1987 | MICHAEL JOHN | RATHBONE | 4 |
| 17/11/1973 | DAVID | SADLER | 4 |
| 25/08/1990 | STEPHEN (STEVE) | SENIOR | 4 |
| 05/09/1891 | James | Sharp | 4 |
| 02/02/1991 | DAVID STEPHEN (DAVE) | THOMPSON | 4 |
| 22/09/1900 | George | Tod | 4 |
| 26/08/1933 | John McD | Torbet | 4 |
| 13/08/1994 | DAVID NEIL | TREBBLE | 4 |
| 13/08/2011 | JUVHEL | TSOUMOU | 4 |
| 29/03/1902 | Joseph (Joe) | Walton | 4 |
| 13/03/1948 | JOSEPH (JOE) | WALTON | 4 |
| 25/12/1937 | Richard (Dickie) | Watmough | 4 |
| 25/08/1984 | PAUL | WILKINS | 4 |
| 29/04/1911 | David R | Anderson | 3 |
| 10/04/2010 | ADAM | BARTON | 3 |
| 25/11/1893 | John (Jack) | Barton | 3 |
| 13/08/2012 | CHRISTOPHER (CHRIS) KELAN | BEARDSLEY | 3 |
| 01/01/1907 | Martin | Becton | 3 |
| 13/09/1890 | James | Brandon | 3 |
| 11/02/1911 | Frederick (Fred) | Broadhurst | 3 |
| 05/09/1992 | SIMON PAUL | BURTON | 3 |
| 15/08/1992 | AARON JOSEPH | CALLAGHAN | 3 |
| 06/08/2011 | CLARKE JAMES | CARLISLE | 3 |
| 18/03/1995 | MATTHEW (MATT) | CARMICHAEL | 3 |
| 05/11/1898 | Jimmy | Chalmers | 3 |
| 10/01/1891 | Bernard | Crossen | 3 |
| 24/08/1949 | WILLIAM CARRUTHERS (WILLIE) | CUNNINGHAM | 3 |
| 23/08/1997 | JULIAN TIMOTHY | DARBY | 3 |
| 16/11/1912 | George | Dawson | 3 |
| 04/03/1896 | Thomas F | Eccleston | 3 |
| 13/10/1888 | John (Jack) | Edwards | 3 |
| 15/08/1992 | LEE EDWARD | FOWLER | 3 |
| 14/11/1925 | Thomas B (Tom) | Gillespie | 3 |
| 03/10/1914 | Duncan C | Grant | 3 |
| 18/02/1911 | John Edward (Jack) | Hall | 3 |
| 04/04/1908 | Edward | Holdsworth | 3 |
| 03/08/2013 | CHRISTOPHER CHARLES | HUMPHREY | 3 |
| 09/02/2010 | MATTHEW (MATTY) | JAMES | 3 |
| 23/08/1986 | ALEXANDER (ALEX) | JONES | 3 |
| 06/08/2005 | DAVID FRANK LLWYD | JONES | 3 |
| 14/04/1984 | MARK THOMAS | JONES | 3 |
| 02/05/2001 | MICHAEL THOMAS JOSEPH | KEANE | 3 |
| 07/11/1995 | KEVIN DANIEL | KILBANE | 3 |
| 16/11/2013 | NEIL MARTIN | KILKENNY | 3 |
| 08/11/1997 | ANTHONY (TONY) | LORMOR | 3 |
| 18/01/2003 | SIMON GEORGE | LYNCH | 3 |
| 16/01/2010 | DANNY | MAYOR | 3 |
| 16/02/1938 | James McLaren (Jimmy) | McIntosh | 3 |
| 22/09/1956 | GORDON | MILNE | 3 |
| 07/08/2010 | CRAIG | MORGAN | 3 |
| 16/09/2005 | ADAM CHRISTOPHER | NOWLAND | 3 |
| 26/12/1960 | GEORGE | ROSS | 3 |
| 25/08/1984 | DALE ANTHONY | RUDGE | 3 |
| 29/08/1931 | Henry Richard (Harry) | Simmons | 3 |
| 15/08/1992 | JOHN | TINKLER | 3 |
| 12/11/1927 | Frank | Ward | 3 |
| 06/04/1993 | LIAM | WATSON | 3 |
| 13/08/2012 | JOHN JOSEPH | WELSH | 3 |
| 23/03/2002 | CLYDE | WIJNHARD | 3 |
| 21/02/1987 | FRANK STEWART | WORTHINGTON | 3 |
| 25/10/1919 | Simpson | Bainbridge | 2 |
| 27/11/1954 | SAMMY | BAIRD | 2 |
| 19/08/1961 | DAVID ERIC | BARBER | 2 |
| 01/09/1914 | John | Barbour | 2 |
| 12/09/1995 | DEAN | BARRICK | 2 |
| 01/12/1900 | John | Beaver | 2 |
| 04/03/1995 | DAVID ROBERT | BECKHAM | 2 |
| 09/03/1996 | PAUL | BIRCH | 2 |
| 18/08/1979 | JOHN HENDERSON | BLACKLEY | 2 |
| 06/10/1981 | THOMAS ANTHONY (TOMMY) | BOOTH | 2 |
| 28/10/1933 | Joseph (Joe) | Brain | 2 |
| 26/12/1913 | Thomas Alfred (Tommy) | Broome | 2 |
| 02/09/1899 | Matthew | Brunton | 2 |
| 02/10/1993 | GREGORY LOUIS (GREG) | CHALLENDER | 2 |
| 05/08/2006 | LIAM CHRISTOPHER | CHILVERS | 2 |
| 14/05/1977 | JOHN (IAN) | COCHRANE | 2 |
| 28/12/1964 | WILLIAM (BILL) | CRANSTON | 2 |
| 15/08/1992 | JONATHAN STEWART (JON) | DAVIDSON | 2 |
| 13/03/1948 | WILLIAM (WILLIE) | DOUGAL | 2 |
| 09/02/1952 | JOSEPH (JOE) | DUNN | 2 |
| 28/08/1925 | Cyril Milner | Eastwood | 2 |
| 15/01/2011 | NATHAN LEVI FONTAINE | ELLINGTON | 2 |
| 03/10/1953 | RAYMOND (RAY) | EVANS | 2 |
| 16/10/1993 | ANDREW BRIAN (ANDY) | FENSOME | 2 |
| 13/08/1994 | TERENCE MAURICE (TERRY) | FLEMING | 2 |
| 22/08/1992 | DAVID JOHN (DAVE) | FLITCROFT | 2 |
| 18/08/2001 | KEVIN WILLIAM | GALLACHER | 2 |
| 12/12/1992 | SHAUN MAURICE | GARNETT | 2 |
| 05/02/1938 | Archibald Campbell E (Archie) | Garrett | 2 |
| 16/01/1908 | Charles S | Gillibrand | 2 |
| 07/09/1901 | Michael | Good | 2 |
| 03/11/1984 | TERENCE IAN (TERRY) | GRAY | 2 |
| 30/08/1919 | William (Billy) | Halligan | 2 |
| 01/10/1977 | SEAN MATTHEW | HASLEGRAVE | 2 |
| 08/09/1888 | Robert (Bob) | Holmes | 2 |
| 04/10/1919 | John | Hosker | 2 |
| 12/08/2014 | JORDAN | HUGILL | 2 |
| 08/12/1888 | John (Jock) | Inglis | 2 |
| 02/01/2012 | JAKE MARIO | JERVIS | 2 |
| 13/08/2012 | KEITH FRANCIS | KEANE | 2 |
| 01/01/1972 | ALAN DAVID | LAMB | 2 |
| 12/03/1991 | MATTHEW ROY | LAMBERT | 2 |
| 26/12/1994 | GRAHAM | LANCASHIRE | 2 |
| 18/08/1962 | STANLEY (STAN) | LAPOT | 2 |
| 22/04/1975 | MARK THOMAS | LAWRENSON | 2 |
| 10/12/1955 | EDWARD (EDDIE) | LEWIS | 2 |
| 09/08/2014 | ANDREW (ANDY) | LITTLE | 2 |
| 02/09/1912 | William (Billy) | Luke | 2 |
| 24/10/1903 | David (Davie) | Maher | 2 |
| 25/12/1947 | WILLIAM (WILLIE) | McCLURE | 2 |
| 27/08/1938 | Terence (Terry) | McGibbons | 2 |
| 08/11/1890 | William | McKennie | 2 |
| 15/10/1904 | Daniel | McKie | 2 |
| 02/03/1912 | James | McKnight | 2 |
| 01/09/1897 | Colin | McLatchie | 2 |
| 06/08/2011 | BRIAN | McLEAN | 2 |
| 07/04/1987 | DAVID BRIAN (DAVE) | MILLER | 2 |
| 17/08/1976 | BARRIE | MITCHELL | 2 |
| 01/09/1928 | John Henry (Jack) | Nelson | 2 |
| 11/03/2008 | TAMAŚ | PRISKIN | 2 |
| 14/02/2012 | CHRISTOPHER (CHRIS) | ROBERTSON | 2 |
| 30/10/1960 | ANTHONY JOSEPH (TONY) | SINGLETON | 2 |
| 12/01/2002 | ERIC | SKORA | 2 |
| 23/09/1899 | Harold (Harry) | Stansfield | 2 |
| 31/08/1929 | David Morton | Steele | 2 |
| 23/03/1985 | IAN DAVID | STEVENS | 2 |
| 08/09/1906 | Harry | Stringfellow | 2 |
| 12/04/1913 | William | Swarbrick | 2 |
| 18/10/1986 | STEVEN JEFFREY (STEVE) | TAYLOR | 2 |
| 29/04/1911 | Robert | Thompson | 2 |
| 17/11/1934 | Joseph Leslie (Les) | Vernon | 2 |
| 18/09/1920 | George Barr | Waddell | 2 |
| 29/08/1981 | MARK | WALSH | 2 |
| 03/09/1910 | William (Billy) | Wareing | 2 |
| 26/01/2010 | DANIEL (DANNY) NLL TACKIE MEMASH | WELBECK | 2 |
| 23/09/1995 | RUSSELL | WILCOX | 2 |
| 01/05/1972 | GARY PETER | WILLIAMS | 2 |
| 22/10/1921 | John (Jonny) | Williamson | 2 |
| 28/03/2006 | KELVIN JAMES | WILSON | 2 |
| 11/01/2014 | SCOTT NIGEL KENNETH | WISEMAN | 2 |
| 06/09/1958 | JOHN EDWARD | WYLIE | 2 |
| 03/09/1894 | Richard | Allan | 1 |
| 13/08/2012 | DAVID OLUWASEUN SEGUN | AMOO | 1 |
| 24/03/2012 | CHUKWUEMEKA (CHUCKS) ADEMOLA AMACHI | ANEKE | 1 |
| 18//09/1909 | Charles Henry | Arthurs | 1 |
| 01/01/1937 | John James (Jack) | Atherton | 1 |
| 23/04/1973 | STUART WILLIAM | BAXTER | 1 |
| 06/09/1986 | MICHAEL (MIKE) | BENNETT | 1 |
| 05/03/1898 | James (Jimmy) | Blessington | 1 |
| 25/04/1914 | John | Bond | 1 |
| 02/09/1995 | MICHAEL ANTHONY | BROWN | 1 |
| 16/01/2012 | HARRY CHARLES | BUNN | 1 |
| 07/11/1998 | DARREN | BYFIELD | 1 |
| 13/08/2012 | SHANE LEWIS | CANSDELL-SHERRIFF | 1 |
| 14/08/2007 | ANDREW THOMAS (ANDY) | CARROLL | 1 |
| 31/12/1904 | John | Catterall | 1 |
| 23/08/1986 | LESLIE (LES) | CHAPMAN | 1 |
| 22/04/1911 | Albert | Chester | 1 |
| 01/02/2011 | LEON MARVIN | CLARKE | 1 |
| 27/02/1965 | ANTHONY GEORGE (TONY) | COLEMAN | 1 |
| 19/09/2009 | NEIL WILLIAM | COLLINS | 1 |
| 10/09/1938 | John (Jackie) | Cox | 1 |
| 02/01/1926 | Joseph Gerald (Joe) | Craven | 1 |
| 25/08/1934 | Ted | Critchley | 1 |
| 13/08/1977 | GRAHAM FREDERICK | CROSS | 1 |
| 04/01/1947 | ALBERT | DAINTY | 1 |
| 21/10/2011 | KEAMMAR | DALEY | 1 |
| 28/08/2004 | OMAR | DALEY | 1 |
| 01/09/1919 | George | Daniel | 1 |
| 01/12/1962 | IAN | DAVIDSON | 1 |
| 30/04/2011 | DANIEL | DEVINE | 1 |
| 06/02/1926 | Tom | Devlin | 1 |
| 02/01/1926 | George James (Jim) | Dickie | 1 |
| 03/03/1894 | Charles | Dickson | 1 |
| 25/08/1962 | JOHN | DONNELLY | 1 |
| 01/01/2011 | JAMIE | DOUGLAS | 1 |
| 06/10/1981 | BARRY | DUNN | 1 |
| 04/04/1921 | Thomas (Tom) | Duxbury | 1 |
| 03/01/2015 | SYLVAN AUGUSTUS | EBANKS-BLAKE | 1 |
| 26/09/1896 | Alex | Findley | 1 |
| 14/01/1992 | STEPHEN KENNETH | FINNEY | 1 |
| 08/12/2012 | LUKE JAMES | FOSTER | 1 |
| 09/09/1932 | David Wilson | Galloway | 1 |
| 13/03/2004 | SCOTT | GEMMILL | 1 |
| 25/12/1914 | Wilfred Bernard (Wilf) | Gillow | 1 |
| 15/09/1888 | Archie | Goddall | 1 |
| 24/10/1992 | DEINIOL WILLIAM THOMAS | GRAHAM | 1 |
| 30/11/1889 | Frederick John Swithin | Gray | 1 |
| 28/03/1992 | COLIN ANTHONY | GREENALL | 1 |
| 21/09/1946 | WILLIAM (WILLIE) | HAMILTON | 1 |
| 07/12/1889 | Charles S | Heaton | 1 |
| 01/02/1930 | Frederick (Fred) | Heaton | 1 |
| 25/10/1913 | William M | Henderson | 1 |
| 07/02/1925 | William (Bill) | Henderson | 1 |
| 29/10/1994 | STEVEN PETER (STEVE) | HOLMES | 1 |
| 21/01/2012 | CHRIS | HOLROYD | 1 |
| 07/09/1901 | Raby (Rabbi) | Howell | 1 |
| 26/03/1960 | JAMES (JIMMY) | HUMES | 1 |
| 14/02/2012 | NICHOLAS (NICKY) BRETT | HUNT | 1 |
| 15/03/1983 | CHRISTOPHER PAUL (CHRIS) | HUNTER | 1 |
| 07/03/2006 | JASON LEE MEE | JARRETT | 1 |
| 26/09/1936 | John (Jack) | Jennings | 1 |
| 25/01/1992 | LEONARD (LENNY) | JOHNROSE | 1 |
| 29/10/2005 | JERMAL PIERRE | JOHNSON | 1 |
| 28/01/1933 | Harry Joseph | Jones | 1 |
| 27/08/1983 | DAVID RONALD (DAVE) | JONES | 1 |
| 15/12/1951 | GORDON WALTER | KAILE | 1 |
| 07/08/2010 | JOSHUA | KING | 1 |
| 17/08/1985 | NIGEL | KEEN | 1 |
| 01/09/1914 | Hugh | Kelly | 1 |
| 04/04/1914 | James | Kennedy | 1 |
| 15/08/1992 | MARK ANTHONY | LEONARD | 1 |
| 27/09/2001 | ANDREW (ANDY) | LONERGAN | 1 |
| 30/09/1895 | George | Lonsdale | 1 |
| 15/08/1987 | JOHN ANTHONY | LOWEY | 1 |
| 26/02/1994 | KEVIN | MAGEE | 1 |
| 28/09/1985 | MICHAEL PAUL (MICK) | MARTIN | 1 |
| 25/08/1993 | TREVOR | MATTHEWSON | 1 |
| 16/09/2000 | BRIAN ROBERT | McBRIDE | 1 |
| 14/10/1893 | James | McCann | 1 |
| 26/11/2011 | JAMIE PAUL | McCOMBE | 1 |
| 07/11/1995 | NEIL RAYMOND | McDONALD | 1 |
| 18/01/1908 | Charles (Charlie) | McFadyen | 1 |
| 17/11/1900 | John (Jonny) | McMahon | 1 |
| 24/01/1891 | Thomas | Metcalfe | 1 |
| 17/01/1920 | James (Jimmy) | Miller | 1 |
| 13/08/2012 | JOHN MICHAEL LEWIS | MOUSINHO | 1 |
| 26/02/1910 | Gresham Frederick (Fred) | Parnell | 1 |
| 21/04/1928 | John | Parry | 1 |
| 18/10/1924 | John William (Jock) | Paterson | 1 |
| 17/03/1965 | BERT | PATRICK | 1 |
| 25/08/1990 | NATHAN JAMES | PEEL | 1 |
| 20/02/2007 | PAVEL | PERGL | 1 |
| 21/12/2012 | ANDY | PROCTER | 1 |
| 02/05/2010 | JAMIE | PROCTOR | 1 |
| 05/02/2002 | PAUL MARK | REID | 1 |
| 24/10/1959 | GARBUTT | RICHARDSON | 1 |
| 13/01/2007 | MICHAEL BARRINGTON | RICKETTS | 1 |
| 12/08/2000 | STEPHEN (STEVE) | ROBINSON | 1 |
| 25/02/1905 | Thomas (Tom) | Rodger | 1 |
| 07/08/2010 | DAREL FRANCIS ROY | RUSSELL | 1 |
| 09/09/1989 | PATRICK JOSEPH (PAT) | SCULLY | 1 |
| 16/09/1899 | George | Smith | 1 |
| 19/12/1908 | Richard | Smith | 1 |
| 30/04/1910 | William E | Spence | 1 |
| 15/02/1997 | MARK | STALLARD | 1 |
| 01/09/1973 | NORBERT PETER (NOBBY) | STILES | 1 |
| 14/01/2006 | BRIAN BENJAMIN | STOCK | 1 |
| 14/08/1993 | CHRISTOPHER STEPHEN (CHRIS) | SULLEY | 1 |
| 30/08/1919 | John Henry (Jack) | Tatton | 1 |
| 05/03/1892 | John S | Taylor | 1 |
| 21/10/1978 | BRIAN JOHN | TAYLOR | 1 |
| 27/09/1969 | ALAN | TINSLEY | 1 |
| 23/11/2009 | MICHAEL WILLIAM | TONGUE | 1 |
| 19/04/2008 | NEAL ANTHONY | TROTMAN | 1 |
| 12/02/2011 | IAIN ROSS | TURNER | 1 |
| 24/11/1984 | PAUL WILLIAM | WELSH | 1 |
| 20/09/1980 | SIMON | WESTWELL | 1 |
| 06/03/1993 | DAVID NEIL | WHALLEY | 1 |
| 09/10/1926 | William Thomas | Whitehead | 1 |
| 06/10/1888 | Richard | Whittle | 1 |
| 04/04/2009 | LEE TREVOR | WILLIAMSON | 1 |
| 05/10/1929 | Albert | Wilson | 1 |
| 02/09/1933 | Francis (Frank) | Wilson | 1 |
| 09/03/1907 | John | Winchester | 1 |
| 12/02/1925 | Thomas George | Woodward | 1 |
| 18/12/1926 | Matthew Spratt (Matty) | Young | 1 |
| 28/03/1987 | PETER RICHARD | ZELEM | 1 |