| Date of PNE Debut | Forenames | Surname | Total PNE Goals |
| 31/08/1946 | (SIR) THOMAS (TOM) | FINNEY | 210 |
| 06/09/1919 | William Thomas (Tommy) | Roberts | 180 |
| 01/05/1972 | ALEXANDER ROBERT (ALEX) | BRUCE | 171 |
| 28/10/1961 | ALEXANDER DOWNIE (ALEX) | DAWSON | 132 |
| 20/08/1955 | THOMAS (TOMMY) | THOMPSON | 128 |
| 09/09/1950 | CHARLES (CHARLIE) | WAYMAN | 117 |
| 08/09/1888 | James D (Jimmy) | Ross | 101 |
| 06/09/1902 | Percy James | Smith | 95 |
| 10/10/1987 | ANTHONY JOSEPH (TONY) | ELLIS | 86 |
| 17/03/1979 | STEPHEN BLAIR (STEVE) | ELLIOTT | 78 |
| 09/08/1997 | JONATHAN PAUL (JON) | MACKEN | 74 |
| 27/11/1948 | AGNES CAMERON | MORRISON | 74 |
| 02/03/1974 | MICHAEL WALTER (MIKE) | ELWISS | 72 |
| 08/12/1923 | George | Harrison | 72 |
| 04/10/1952 | JAMES CUNNINGHAM (JiMMY) | BAXTER | 71 |
| 19/02/1985 | GARY NICHOLAS | BRAZIL | 71 |
| 12/12/1931 | Edward Cashfield (Ted) | Harper | 69 |
| 27/03/1999 | GRAHAM | ALEXANDER | 65 |
| 21/11/1891 | Francis (Frank) | Becton | 65 |
| 25/08/1934 | James Morton (Bud) | Maxwell | 65 |
| 09/10/1937 | Robert (Bobby) | Beattie | 62 |
| 14/03/2001 | RICHARD PAUL WESLEY | CRESSWELL | 58 |
| 19/09/1953 | DENNIS | HATSELL | 58 |
| 10/09/1919 | Roland Thomas | Woodhouse | 58 |
| 03/02/1934 | James (Jimmy) | Dougal | 57 |
| 02/11/1963 | BRIAN CAMERON | GODFREY | 57 |
| 31/08/1946 | WILLIAM DOWNING (WILLIE) | McINTOSH | 54 |
| 28/03/1927 | Norman | Robson | 54 |
| 17/08/1985 | JOHN WILLIAM | THOMAS | 54 |
| 23/09/1925 | Alexander Wilson (Alex) | James | 53 |
| 10/01/2013 | JOSEPH (JOE) ALAN | GARNER | 51 |
| 27/08/1927 | Alexander M (Alec) | Reid | 50 |
| 05/09/1896 | Thomas Peet (Tom) | Pratt | 49 |
| 31/08/1935 | Francis Joseph (Frank) | O'Donnell | 48 |
| 27/08/1955 | SAMUEL MCGREGOR (SAMMY) | TAYLOR | 48 |
| 30/12/2000 | DAVID JONATHAN | HEALY | 45 |
| 17/10/1987 | WARREN GARTON | JOYCE | 45 |
| 29/11/1986 | GARY | SWANN | 45 |
| 28/09/1901 | Harry Melbourne | Wilcox | 45 |
| 07/09/1968 | GERALD (GERRY) | INGRAM | 44 |
| 06/09/1913 | Frederick (Freddie) | Osborn | 44 |
| 24/11/1928 | George Wolfenden | Bargh | 43 |
| 24/03/1894 | Adam | Henderson | 43 |
| 27/01/2007 | NEIL ANDREW | MELLOR | 43 |
| 25/12/1951 | ROBERT JOHN (BOBBY) | FOSTER | 42 |
| 03/11/1990 | LEE | ASHCROFT | 41 |
| 19/04/1989 | GRAHAM PAUL | SHAW | 41 |
| 08/09/1888 | George (Georgie) | Drummond | 40 |
| 26/12/1960 | DAVID CHARLES (DAVE) | WILSON | 39 |
| 13/11/1902 | Robert (Dickie) | Bond | 37 |
| 31/08/1946 | JOSEPH KENNETH (KEN) | HORTON | 37 |
| 15/01/2005 | DAVID JAMES | NUGENT | 37 |
| 28/08/1925 | William Fraser (Willie) | Russell | 35 |
| 08/09/1888 | John B (Jack) | Gordon | 34 |
| 31/08/1935 | Hugh | O'Donnell | 34 |
| 16/03/1968 | WILLIAM JOHN (WILLIE) | IRVINE | 33 |
| 09/12/1996 | PAUL STEPHEN | McKENNA | 32 |
| 25/09/1937 | George | Mutch | 32 |
| 09/04/1904 | James | Wilson | 32 |
| 10/08/2002 | RICARDO DWAYNE | FULLER | 31 |
| 31/08/1964 | ERNEST (ERNIE) | HANNIGAN | 31 |
| 04/01/1947 | ANDREW(ANDY) | McLAREN | 31 |
| 15/03/1997 | KURT | NOGAN | 31 |
| 30/08/2008 | JONATHAN (JON) | PARKIN | 31 |
| 30/10/1960 | ALAN | SPAVIN | 31 |
| 01/01/1896 | James (Jim) | Stevenson | 31 |
| 30/10/1960 | PETER | THOMPSON | 31 |
| 19/10/1957 | ALEXANDER GEORGE (ALEC) | ALSTON | 30 |
| 01/10/1973 | GORDON MICHAEL | COLEMAN | 30 |
| 10/10/1981 | JOHN | KELLY | 30 |
| 05/09/1896 | Alexander (Sandy) | Brown | 29 |
| 14/09/1957 | DEREK | MAYERS | 29 |
| 11/031899 | Andrew | Gara | 28 |
| 05/09/1903 | John (Jack) | Bell | 27 |
| 27/01/1973 | MELVILLE GEORGE (MEL) | HOLDEN | 27 |
| 14/09/1889 | Nicholas John (Nick) | Ross | 27 |
| 02/03/1991 | LEE | CARTWRIGHT | 26 |
| 06/11/1909 | David Prophet | McLean | 26 |
| 01/11/1997 | DAVID | EYRES | 25 |
| 08/09/1888 | John | Goddall | 25 |
| 10/10/1987 | BRIAN JOHN | MOONEY | 25 |
| 19/08/1961 | ALFRED GEORGE (ALFIE) | BIGGS | 24 |
| 21/08/1993 | MICHAEL KEVIN (MIKE) | CONROY | 24 |
| 01/09/2007 | PAUL | GALLAGHER | 24 |
| 18/09/2010 | IAIN EDWARD | HUME | 24 |
| 17/02/1964 | FRANCIS (FRANK) | LEE | 24 |
| 25/04/1959 | DAVE | SNEDDON | 24 |
| 12/01/2008 | CHRISTOPHER ALAN | BROWN | 23 |
| 21/02/1903 | Herbert | Danson | 23 |
| 13/10/1906 | Charles | Dawson | 23 |
| 02/09/1911 | Benjamin Haigh (Benny) | Green | 23 |
| 19/03/1963 | NOBERT (NOBBY) | LAWTON | 23 |
| 15/11/1913 | James Lowrey | Macauley | 23 |
| 28/08/1920 | Arrchibald (Archie) | Rawlings | 23 |
| 05/09/1891 | Moses | Sanders | 23 |
| 30/08/1930 | Thomas (Tom) | Scott | 23 |
| 28/02/1995 | SIMON | DAVEY | 22 |
| 14/08/2004 | CALLUM IAIN | DAVIDSON | 22 |
| 27/10/1928 | Alexander (Sandy) | Hair | 22 |
| 02/09/1911 | William (Bill) | Kirby | 22 |
| 19/10/1929 | James (Jim) | McCelland | 22 |
| 19/11/2004 | PATRICK | AGYEMANG | 21 |
| 31/03/1975 | RICHARD BLAIR (RICKY) | THOMSON | 21 |
| 04/12/1993 | JAMES IAN COOK | BRYSON | 20 |
| 24/12/1932 | George Arthur | Fitton | 20 |
| 06/10/1984 | NIGEL PATRICK | GREENWOOD | 20 |
| 06/01/1973 | WILLIAM ANTHONY (TONY) | MORLEY | 20 |
| 27/08/1988 | MARK ANDREW | PATTERSON | 20 |
| 05/04/1902 | Frank | Pearson | 20 |
| 01/10/1892 | David | Russell | 20 |