| Player | PNE Debut | Current Club | Signed |
| Graham Alexander | 27/03/1999 | Burnley | Aug-07 from PNE |
| Dickson Etuhu | 29/01/2002 | Fulham | Aug-08 from Sunderland |
| Ricardo Fuller | 10/08/2002 | Stoke | Aug-06 from Southampton |
| David Healy | 30/12/2000 | Sunderland | Aug-08 from Fulham |
| Matt Hill | 15/01/2005 | Wolves | Sept 08 from PNE |
| David Jones | 06/08/2005 | Wolves | June 08 from Derby |
| Kevin Kilbane | 07/11/1995 | Hull | Jan 09 from Wigan |
| Tyrone Mears | 19/10/2002 | Burnley | June 09 from Derby |
| Carlo Nash | 02/04/2005 | Everton | Sept 08 from Wigan |
| David Nugent | 15/01/2005 | Burnley | Sept 09 from Pompey (on loan) |
| Danny Pugh | 05/06/2006 | Stoke | Nov 07 from PNE |